A question for the audience · 18+
Would you keep this scene?
At the school concert, a whispered insult draws a quiet objection. Does this moment serve the story of JEWISH?
The first school concert
The Sharpies perform at MASA for parents, teachers, honored guests and sponsors. Their arrangement grows around Aviva’s voice, Oksana and Paloma’s violins, and Tyron’s pulse. Principal Vanderbilt sits beside a close friend. Bunny Montgomery, the school’s principal benefactor, is a few seats away, watching Joseph Shapiro at the side piano.
From the current screenplay draft (v07, scene 57), not a final approved script. Vanderbilt whispers an antisemitic remark to her friend. The friend objects quietly. Bunny and Joseph do not hear the whisper.
Read the scene from the current draft
The dialogue below contains an antisemitic slur spoken by a fictional character.
Vanderbilt (under the music, to her friend)
“They certainly found a way to get everyone’s attention. But our benefactor is apparently charmed by our little kike.”The friend looks at her. No laugh.
Friend
“Elaine. Don’t call him that.”Vanderbilt keeps her face toward the stage. Her friend shifts slightly away. Bunny has not heard the whisper.
The scene returns to Joseph, unaware of the insult, helping a student find an entrance. What does the friend’s objection reveal? Does this moment deepen the characters and serve the story?
Read the film’s story · Meet Bunny Montgomery · Meet Vanderbilt · Meet Mr. Shapiro
Be the first to share your view
No responses have been reviewed yet. Prepare your feedback below, then send it by email. Results will appear after review.
This is a conversation with the writer. The totals show reviewed email responses. Your choices are not sent or stored by this page. Prepare and review a draft, then send it yourself by email. No response is published automatically, and story decisions remain with the creator.